Short answer… to get a replacement part quote from a photo, we need three or four clear pictures with a ruler (or a coin, for scale) in the frame, how many you need, when you need them, and what the part does. For basic parts, that’s it. With those, a design engineer in our network can usually price the job without ever touching the original.
How fast? On a real project with a design fee paid toward the effort, a quote can come back within hours, and a day or two is common. The You3Dit community tends to jump in with comments quickly, so any gaps in the requirements get cleared up early. From there, a fabrication quote can arrive as soon as a design is submitted to the project. Our leadership sees that as a great moment: the fabrication quote shows how manufacturable each submitted design is, which helps the client pick the option with the best downstream manufacturing cost.
Compare that with waiting on the OEM. We ordered an original door-switch bracket for a wine cooler, and several years later that order still hasn’t shipped. We would have liked to validate our design against the reference piece, but it never arrived, so we reverse engineered the bracket and now offer it in our shop for $19.95 in PETG.
This is for anyone who keeps equipment running: plants, garages, laundromats, campuses, property managers, any facility with a part that’s broken, backordered, or no longer made.
A one-line request that became a part
A good example is about as plain as a request gets. The whole project description read: “need a copy of this toilet paper dispenser.” The part turned out to be the roller, a cylinder with a small peg and flange on each end.
A designer in our network modeled it, and the model shows the kind of small revision that photos alone can’t settle: the pegs were extended by 1 mm on each side. Our team in Berkeley, CA then printed four rollers in white plastic on a Printrbot Simple Metal, a desktop FDM printer. See the project: Toilet dispenser fix.
How did they hold up? The customer was a laundromat owner and a repeat customer, so the rollers must have been at least sufficient, if not better than acceptable. There wasn’t any follow-up, and we generally assume no news is good news.
How to shoot the photos
Put something of known size in every shot. A ruler or tape measure is best. One hardware startup simply wrote in its request that the part was “about the same size of a deck of cards (if your scaling is weird).” That one line saved a round of back-and-forth.
Leadership’s tip from a recent project: line the object up along its axes of symmetry, as best you can. In practice that means square-on shots of the front, side, and top, not a single angled phone photo. Add a close-up of anything that mates with something else: holes, slots, clips, threads. If it’s broken, photograph the broken edge too, and a shot of where the part sits in the machine.
Have calipers? Measure the critical features (hole diameters, overall length, wall thickness) and write them on a sketch or right on the photo.
The answers that set the price
Photos tell us the shape. These tell us the price:
- Quantity. Design time is paid once, so 10 parts rarely cost 10 times what 1 does. As we wrote back in 2017, the cost to design one part can often be the same as the cost to produce 100.
- Deadline. One customer needed 8 small parts, in left- and right-hand pairs, to keep screws from touching the glass they pass through, and needed them by Friday. Saying so up front let the designer and fabricator plan around it. Rush jobs cost more.
- Environment. Heat, oil, sunlight, constant flexing, or a load it has to carry. This decides between PETG, ABS, nylon, or metal.
- Fit. What does it press into, screw onto, or slide over? A press fit needs tighter dimensions than a cover that just sits in place.
Once a small part is modeled, the machine time and material are tiny: 34 minutes and 5 grams of plastic here. Most of a first-time quote is the design work, which is why a clear photo and clear answers bring the price down.
What a modeled part costs vs. a new one
Parts that already have a design file are just print jobs. The replacement parts in our shop run from $4.95 for a set of toy bolts and nuts to $38 for a nylon parking keypad button support. A new part adds design and usually one prototype round.
For super simple parts, plan on $100 and up in fabrication costs. Real engineered parts are a different game, and as our leadership puts it, the game really doesn’t start until you have a couple grand to throw at it. Leadership’s view: $1K for design is remarkably cheap in the grand scheme of things to get a good engineer’s time on something, when a fully burdened mechanical engineer in the Bay Area probably costs about $1K per day (8 hours).
The payoff is in who does that design. If the You3Dit designer understands that the part will be digitally manufactured, they can put time into solving the challenge at hand AND the manufacturability challenge at the same time.
When a photo isn’t enough
Some parts hide what matters: internal channels, fine threads, a tight bearing fit, or a curved surface that’s hard to read from pictures. In those cases the designer may ask for measurements, a 3D scan, or the part itself in the mail. That way the first prototype fits instead of becoming an expensive guess.
Send us the photo
Got a broken part on your desk right now? Post your project for free with your photos, quantity, and deadline, and our network of 790+ vetted fabricators will quote it. Already have a CAD file? Get an instant quote.
What’s the worst part photo you’ve ever had to work from? Tell us in the comments.
